Egan's Effort Criticized, Even Within The Gop

October 06, 1991|By Doreen Carvajal, Inquirer Staff Writer Staff writers Marc Duvoisin and Martha Woodall contributed to this article

Philadelphia's cops and tough-talking Joe Egan should have mixed like law and order. They cheered him as he entered their union hall and booed his opponent, Democrat Edward G. Rendell.

Then they endorsed Rendell.

Port Richmond Rotarians and rowhouse Republican Joe Egan should have mixed like dark beer and kielbasa.

But on a September morning, Egan's stand-in, ward leader John Taylor, had a hard time telling the Rotarians exactly what Egan would do as mayor.

Nine weeks after launching his long-shot campaign, Joseph M. Egan Jr. is a man battling more than fatigue, allergies and Democrats. The novice candidate is also under fire for running a lackluster, issueless, and often disorganized campaign.

Story continues below.

And that's what some of his allies say.

Egan has yet to call a news conference to announce a substantive position or detailed solution for some of the city's thorniest problems, such as crime, fiscal disarray and homelessness.

He has sought to make his lack of proposals a plus. Last week he blasted Rendell for serving up too many ideas that are unrealistic and misleading.

"Boy, he's got a position paper on everything. And boy, that's got to scare everybody," Egan told a group of college and high school journalists scribbling down his words.

Yesterday, after taking two days off to rest and recuperate from a sinus condition, Egan charged back into the campaign, promising a blueprint for his new government in the next two weeks.

"I've taken some criticism for this. . . . and it's valid criticism," Egan said yesterday. "They say, 'Where's his position papers? Where's his position papers?' And the reason I have no position papers - it could have been easy for me because I could have taken Rendell's, Sam Katz's, turned it around, looked at what I could live with, and put out Joe Egan position papers. But I didn't for a very good reason. I wanted to find out what was going on in the city."

The campaign has gone well, he said in a Friday night telephone interview, and voters are receptive. He would like more money, more attention from the press. "Let me tell you, it's been a race. And it's a race now."

Egan is not always so upbeat. In a business that, for better or worse, demands glib talk, he sometimes seems too candid.

At a social workers forum hosted by the Children, Youth and Family Council, Egan was asked what people expected the next mayor to accomplish.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|