Demonstrating The Orchestral Possibilities Inherent In The Piano Quintet

Posted: April 25, 1996

The piano quintet from A to somewhere near Y was the subject of the Musicians from Marlboro in their concert Tuesday at the Convention Center. The ensemble played the founding work in the form, Schumann's Quintet in E flat, after playing John Harbison's descendant, his Piano Quintet, written in 1981.

Harbison found in the grouping of string quartet and piano many of the same orchestral stirrings that Schumann had exploited. Cellist Marcy Rosen explained that the work had been written as a tribute to painter Georgia O'Keeffe. Its references, however, were musical rather than visual, for Harbison created, in five movements, evocations of moods typical of Mendelssohn, Haydn and even Mahler.

The ``Capriccio'' section took its mood from Mendelssohn's scherzos, and the ``Burletta,'' for all its big rough nature, spoke of Haydn's late minuet movements. The music made its impact with its spaciousness, the use of the piano as rhythmic propellant, and clear textures.

The last movement, an elegy, seemed oddly attached to four preceding movements that projected strongly affirmative, even playful moods. The elegy is a big lament that sounded like the end of some other work, for the first four proclaimed the joy of sound, of melodic play, and in the ``Capriccio,'' the fascination of Mendelssohn's light, quick manner.

These players gave the Schumann quintet a youthful, buoyant voice. The second movement, which can be a haunted, gray outcry, sounded much more cheerful than that, and provided more of a complement than a contrast to the other movements. Pianist Stephen Prutsman proved an elegant player through this work.

Catherine Cho, Daniel Panner and Marcy Rosen opened the concert with Beethoven's String Trio in C minor (Op. 9, No. 3). The performance was finely joined, with the three players fitting sound and gesture in ways that helped the music to expand. The Adagio movement was the most memorable. They found in it depths beyond the usual reading of the score.

MUSICIANS FROM MARLBORO Presented Tuesday by the Philadelphia Chamber Music Society. No additional performances.

|
|
|
|
|