Bucks to pay $345,000 to settle prison sexual-misconduct case

Posted: September 11, 2002

Seven women who accused male staff members in the Bucks County prison of repeated sexual misconduct will receive a total of $345,000 in a settlement reached yesterday.

Criminal charges against three guards and a counselor were filed in May 2001 after a three-month investigation by county detectives. All four were convicted of the charges.

Alan Yatkin, a Center City attorney who represented one of the women, said yesterday's settlement conference was the first attempt to resolve the case, which was filed in federal court in Philadelphia in December.

"The case was starting to get expensive, and it seemed like the right time for all of us to settle," he said.

County Solicitor Guy Matthews confirmed the settlement amount. He said the county commissioners were being "fiscally responsible" by avoiding a potentially costly trial.

"While the county truly believes there's no responsibility here, we're still involved in a lawsuit involving the actions of some rogue officers," he said.

Former Capt. William McMullen is serving a three- to 23-month sentence. Former guard Jeffrey Budd received two years' probation. Robert Lee Gilmore Jr., a former sergeant at the prison, was sentenced to six to 23 months on house arrest. Receiving the stiffest sentence was Peter Doyle, a former counselor and guard who is serving 2 1/2 to 5 years in state prison.

In her complaint, Yatkin's client said she had sexual contact with Budd and Gilmore on numerous occasions beginning in 1999 while on work release at a Warrington pizzeria.

According to the suit, the county and former prison Warden J. Allen Nesbitt failed to protect her and other female inmates "from being victims of correctional officers' sexual predation and assaults."

Contact Peter Sigal at 215-345-7768 or psigal@phillynews.com.

|
|
|
|
|