Radnor Drops Fees Now, refund the victims' money

Posted: February 14, 2007

Radnor Township officials came to their senses Monday and began to repeal an outrageous ordinance that required out-of-town drivers involved in minor accidents to pay for "police services."

Now the township needs to go one step further. It should refund approximately $40,000 to the motorists who were intimidated into paying these fees.

File this one under: "What were they thinking?" In April 2006, the township commissioners enacted a law intended to recover money from the insurance companies of non-residents involved in traffic accidents. The plan was for an Ohio firm with the vaguely sinister name of Cost Recovery Corp. to bill insurers for the cost of police response. The commissioners' flawed thinking seemed to be that local taxes shouldn't be spent on coming to the aid of non-local folk.

But many insurers refused to pay. When that happened, CRC sent letters to the motorists, informing them that the bill was their "financial responsibility." For example, Shantel West of Yeadon was billed $715.08 for three police officers who responded to her fender-bender. Mark Harbison of Paoli got a bill for $322.20 for a police officer he didn't summon to a three-car crash that wasn't his fault.

Drivers were not legally liable for the costs, but many of them didn't know that and paid up. Worse, some motorists who questioned the bills said police told them that they had to pay. At best, this voluntary "fee" system became a form of coercion. At worst, it was borderline fraud.

The commissioners are set to repeal the ordinance later this month; in the meantime it's not being enforced. Commissioner Dave Cannan proposed immediate refunds for drivers, saying his "gut feeling is these people need to be paid back."

His fellow commissioners should listen to Cannan's gut. These drivers were induced to pay under false pretenses. Whether or not the township knew of its collection agency's obnoxious tactics, the township launched this misguided program. It owes those drivers an apology, and their money back.

|
|
|
|
|