The photo was taken, the two men looking pleasant enough, though they gripped a bat instead of each other's hands.
But Freddie Schmidt, a Phillies pitcher, told Eig that as the photographer snapped the picture, he heard Chapman say, "Jackie, you know you're a good ballplayer but you're still a nigger to me."
A mythology has grown up around those Phillies-Dodgers series. Some claim a black cat was set loose on the Shibe Park field. Others say fans here hurled watermelon chunks. If so, contemporary accounts ignored the incidents and Eig has never been able to confirm them.