Changing Skyline: Thanks - but no thanks

City keeps its view narrow, rejecting a N. Phila. resident-friendly plan.

January 25, 2008|By Inga Saffron, Inquirer Architecture Critic

Pia Varma and Steven Nebel were so confident that Philadelphia officials would approve their high-minded plan for a 51-unit, environmentally correct, architect-designed condo project in a tattered pocket of North Philadelphia that they sent out printed invitations urging friends to witness the granting of their variances by the Zoning Board of Adjustment.

But the happy event never came to pass. Their Jan. 8 hearing was the final day of operations for Mayor Street's zoning board, and members were in no mood for young visionaries. Perhaps if the architect-entrepreneurs hadn't just set up shop in Philadelphia, they wouldn't have been blindsided by what happened next.

Story continues below.

In quick order, Varma and Nebel were told they had 10 minutes to describe their development, called High Street. Officials from the Commerce and Planning Departments took the stage to denounce their construction project. The zoning board finished things off by announcing it wouldn't issue a ruling. The pair left the room more shaken than the day they heard about the triple homicide a block from their two kitty-corner sites, at the intersection of Germantown and Cecil B. Moore Avenues.

Given the beleaguered state of the neighborhood, you'd expect the city to welcome the pair's proposal for new housing with rousing cheers. The neighborhood group has sung its praises. But instead, the city told the young developers it was committed to preserving their junk-strewn, half-acre lots in the event an industrial user came along.

"You get the feeling," Nebel later grumbled to me, "that cities are the worst redliners."

The surprise here isn't that Philadelphia believes it should set aside land for industry. Even though we're deep into the post-manufacturing age, every city needs places where fabricators, warehouses, truck depots, junkyards and other messy enterprises can feel at ease.

But this enclave claimed by the Kensington South Neighborhood Advisory Council is a place that abounds with vacant tracts. You can hardly walk a couple of blocks without bumping into one of the great redbrick relics of Philadelphia's industrial heyday, like the Rieger & Gretz brewery on Germantown Avenue. With so much available land, why keep those tiny parcels in the deep freeze?

1 | 2 | 3 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|