Their lawyers maintain both are innocent and indicate they will fight the charges.
Honeycutt is charged with statutory sexual assault and other crimes after two boys, 15 and 14, accused her of engaging in sexual activity with them April 11 and 12 at Long-Higham's house.
Long-Higham, who police say stood by while the crimes took place and at one point warned the teens not to tell anyone, faces misdemeanor charges of endangering the welfare of children and corruption of minors.
In court documents, police say Honeycutt started sexual conversations, then stripped, danced, kissed one of the boys, and invited others to touch her after a larger coed party wound down into a sleepover for six boys.
Ultimately, police say, Honeycutt enticed two of the teens into the shower, where she had sexual intercourse with the 15-year-old and engaged in other sexual activity with the 14-year-old.
Police were contacted a few days later after "one of the boys who had sexual contact with Honeycutt was thinking about it and felt badly," Lower Makefield Police Chief Ken Coluzzi said. "He was somewhat traumatized by it. He went to his parents, who contacted police."
Court documents indicate that three of the other five boys corroborated the 15-year-old's account. Coluzzi said neither Honeycutt nor Long-Higham had cooperated with the investigation.
Their versions may differ considerably from those of the boys, said Eriksen, who represents Honeycutt. He said that as many as 20 youths had been in and out of the house that evening, and that their accounts did not match.
"I don't know" what happened, Eriksen said, "but I do know that you've got 20 witnesses, and there's different versions of what everybody saw. Some are inconsistent with what the main victims are saying."
