Meat eaters, on the other hand, will find the topping selection wanting, with only a few slim slices of nitrate-free sausage and pepperoni (plus the occasional morsel of chicken) to sate the carnivore.
It's a serious shortcoming that could so easily be remedied with some big, craggy crumbles of fire-roasted fresh sausage (better texture than those soulless sliced rounds), some crispy nuggets of Southern smoked bacon, or some silky folds of fresh prosciutto. And Baker, a longtime vegetarian, says he's committed to improving the meat toppings soon, as long as they don't weigh down the crusts, which get sliced into a checkerboard of small pieces. The gooey chicken alfredo that drooped with too much cheese into the center of one pizza special we ordered was a good example of one such heavy-handed mistake.
In terms of pizza basics, though, Baker's straightforward pies are already off to a great start. A plan to start making the mozzarella in-house would begin to elevate them to the next level.
A few more choices on the appetizer list wouldn't hurt either, though we enjoyed all the starters Earth Bread + Brewery did offer, including some notably fresh salads, a creamy pumpkin bisque, and a nice cheese plate with tasty pear compote.
One concession to this restaurant's kitchen limitations I didn't mind: desserts brought in from the Night Kitchen in nearby Chestnut Hill, which reminded me, with its fluffy chocolate cakes, rich ganache tarts, and buttery shortbread cookies, why I still consider it one of the city's best home-style bakeries.
But for the most part, this newcomer's charm lies in the magic of its handcrafted bounty, the delicacy of its wood-fired pizzas, the character of its original beers, and the personality of a space so well suited to its neighborhood. With the heat-charred flour of these flatbreads still tickling my lips on my way back home to Center City, I pondered the question once more: What could be more satisfying than great pizza and beer? A destination for pizza and beer this good in my own neighborhood.
Next week, restaurant critic Craig LaBan reviews Melograno near Rittenhouse Square. Contact him at 215-854-2593 or claban@phillynews.com.