Video sharpens focus on raid

Store owner's hidden back-up shows cops snipping security-camera wires

March 30, 2009|By WENDY RUDERMAN & BARBARA LAKER, rudermw@phillynews.com 215-854-2860
Image 1 of 4
  • A still image taken from a security-camera backup system video shows a hand with a knife reaching to cut the cord to a camera during a police raid of a West Oak Lane store. The camera was positioned behind the front counter.
  • A still image taken from a security-camera backup system video shows a hand with a knife reaching to cut the cord to a camera during a police raid of a West Oak Lane store. The camera was positioned behind the front counter.
  • Store owner Jose Duran alleges that narcotics officers trashed his West Oak Lane grocery during a Sept. 11, 2007, raid. This photo was supplied by Duran. He also said the officers helped themselves to chips, sodas, cakes and deli sandwiches.

THE NARCOTICS officers knew they were being watched on video surveillance moments after they entered the bodega.

Officer Jeffrey Cujdik told store owner Jose Duran that police were in search of tiny ziplock bags often used to package drugs. But, during the September 2007 raid, Cujdik and fellow squad members seemed much more interested in finding every video camera in the West Oak Lane store.

"I got like seven or eight eyes," shouted Officer Thomas Tolstoy, referring to the cameras, as the officers glanced up. "There's one outside. There is one, two, three, four in the aisles, and there's one right here somewhere."

For the next several minutes, Tolstoy and other Narcotics Field Unit officers systematically cut wires to cameras until those "eyes" could no longer see.

Then, after the officers arrested Duran and took him to jail, nearly $10,000 in cash and cartons of Marlboros and Newports were missing from the locked, unattended store, Duran alleges. The officers guzzled sodas and scarfed down fresh turkey hoagies, Little Debbie fudge brownies and Cheez-Its, he said.

What the officers didn't count on was that Duran's high-tech video system had a hidden backup hard-drive. The backup downloaded the footage to his private Web site before the wires were cut.

Although Duran has no video of the alleged looting, he has a 10-minute video that shows the officers using a bread knife, pliers, milk crates and their hands to disable the surveillance system.

The officers didn't "touch the money with the system looking," said Duran, who came to the United States from the Dominican Republic 15 years ago and has no prior criminal record in Philadelphia.

They touched "the money after they destroy all the system," he said.

Duran, 28, of South Jersey, a technology buff, said that he was upset that the officers had wrecked his $15,000 surveillance system.

"That was his main complaint - that they destroyed his surveillance system," Duran's attorney, Sonte Anthony Reavis, said last week. "I believed him."

Duran's video bolsters allegations by eight other Philadelphia store owners who said that Cujdik and other officers destroyed or cut wires to surveillance cameras. Those store owners also said that after the wires were cut, cigarettes, batteries, cell phones, food and drinks were taken. The Daily News reported the allegations March 20.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|