Crossing Fumo

Property owner won't sell? Fumo's response: Try to jack up taxes.

May 05, 2009|By Joseph Tanfani and Mark Fazlollah, Inquirer Staff Writers
Image 1 of 6
  • Alan Hunter outside the former St. Philip Neri parish school complex near Second and Christian Streets that he bought in 1997.
  • Alan Hunter outside the former St. Philip Neri parish school complex near Second and Christian Streets that he bought in 1997.
  • Former State Sen. Vincent J. Fumo and his lawyer Dennis Cogan (left) leave the federal courthouse in Philadelphia during Fumo's recent corruption trial. (Tony Fitts )
  • Christian Marrone, Fumo's son-in-law, was handed the task of trying to persuade Alan Hunter to sell the former Catholic school property he had bought near Second and Christian Streets in South Philadelphia. (Tony Fitts )
  • Fumo's mansion on Green Street. (Tony Fitts )
  • Alan Hunter says he feels a mixture of irritation and admiration for Fumo's relentlessness in trying to control his South Philadelphia neighborhood. "Wouldn't you like a Gen. Patton on your side?" he asked. (Tony Fitts )
  • Ruth Arnao was executive director of former State Sen. Vincent J. Fumo's South Philadelphia nonprofit, Citizens' Alliance for Better Neighborhoods. She was convicted along with him at his corruption trial in March. (Tony Fitts )

Part three of three.

When Alan and Sheila Hunter decided to move into an old convent in South Philadelphia, they saw beauty behind the asbestos that hung from the ceiling and the plywood that covered the walls.

"We came into the chapel and my wife started to cry," Alan Hunter said in an interview. "You could feel the presence of the nuns who had lived here."

There was nothing holy about what happened after that.

Then-State Sen. Vincent J. Fumo wanted the property for a charter school. He leaned hard on Hunter to sell.

When the high-pressure tactics didn't work, an enraged Fumo decided to "really f- him over."

Story continues below.

His weapon: the city Board of Revision of Taxes.

In an e-mail to an aide, Fumo issued orders demanding that Joseph A. Russo, then a BRT assessor, jack up Hunter's tax bill.

Russo, in turn, spoke with a colleague, suggesting that she look at whether the property's taxes should be raised, according to people familiar with the matter. The next year, Hunter's property assessment more than doubled.

In a brief interview, Russo, who now sits on the board of the BRT, said he could not remember the incident. He declined further comment.

Another BRT board member said the allegations of interference in assessments, if true, would be not just a conflict but a gross violation of BRT policies.

"How could you condone it?" asked Russell Nigro, a former state Supreme Court justice who said he did not know the facts of the case. "How could you condone what, in my opinion, is probably a crime?"

The city's inspector general is now investigating.

The story of the old Catholic school and adjacent convent, pieced together through interviews, board records, and evidence in Fumo's federal corruption trial, shows how the senator's influence infiltrated the Board of Revision of Taxes. This obscure, heavily politicized agency has enormous power. By setting real estate values, it effectively determines what everyone in Philadelphia pays in property taxes.

The seven board members who run the agency are appointed by Philadelphia's judges - many of whom, in turn, would have a tough time getting elected without backing from Fumo and other party leaders. Along with U.S. Rep. Robert Brady, the Democratic Party chief, Fumo has used his muscle to push allies into seats on the BRT board.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|