Reading Terminal Top 40

A teen reviewer dishes on the fare - nearly all of it

October 15, 2009|By BEN ZAUZMER, For the Daily News
Image 1 of 5
  • The soft pretzels at Miller's have a buttery twist.
  • The soft pretzels at Miller's have a buttery twist.
  • Ben en-joyed the fare at Dutch Eating Place.
  • Food vendorsat the Reading Terminal Market offer something for just about any taste.
  • The pastrami is a winner at Herschel's East Side Deli.
  • Ben ponders the cheese at Salumeria.

SOME RESTAURANT reviewers are trained epicures, with a fine taste for all things digestible. Some are TV personalities who try to eat as much junk as they can in as little time as possible. Me? I'm just a kid, a kid who had a noble goal: to eat at every Reading Terminal Market food stand.

For those of you who don't know Reading Terminal Market, it is paradise - a conglomeration of more restaurants, meat and produce vendors, bakeries, candy and craft shops in one block than there are cells in the body.

It is Philadelphia.

I happened to have internships just a few historic blocks from Reading Terminal this past summer, so it soon became my daily lunch spot. Here, ranked from best to, well, not the best, is my assessment of 40 restaurants and food merchants at Reading Terminal Market.

Story continues below.

You may be asking yourself what culinary expertise I have to take on this monumental and long-overdue task. Please stop asking. I'm going to do it anyway.

Typical restaurant reviews grade on criteria such as atmosphere, service and taste. For Reading Terminal, that would be a waste of precious time that could be spent eating more food at Reading Terminal.

The place already has the greatest atmosphere in the Northern Hemisphere (only because I have never been to the southern one). Just about every stand will dish out your food in well under 10 minutes. And delicious does not begin to describe any of these restaurants.

To solve the criteria problem, I used a different rating system. If, after the first bite, I exclaimed to the bewildered guy sitting next to me, "This tastes better than heaven!" the restaurant made the top third. If I yelled to a frightened waitress, "This tastes like heaven!" it made the middle third. If I announced to the security guard, "Hmmm . . . tastes like purgatory . . ., " it was in the bottom third.

I also created two categories, one for meals and one for desserts and other stuff. To further distinguish among them, I used my man's intuition - I think that exists.

Bon appétit, which is French for something.

Meals

 

1. Dutch Eating Place

 

There was a long line on that fateful day, but I was the only solo in line, so the kind waitress in Amish garb quickly found me a spot. Everything on the menu looked like it could fill the soul with happiness, but the chicken pot pie grabbed hold of me and, for the next transcendent half-hour, it did not let go.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|