Bob Ford: Brian Westbrook's return stirs debate over the risks of playing after a concussion.

November 15, 2009|By Bob Ford, Inquirer Columnist
Image 1 of 3
  • Eagles running back Brian Westbrook (center) has been out of the lineup for two games following a concussion. Should he return?
  • Eagles running back Brian Westbrook (center) has been out of the lineup for two games following a concussion. Should he return?
  • Penn's Douglas H. Smith, above, disagrees with Eagles trainer Rick Burkholder, below, on concussions.

When the trainers got to Brian Westbrook as he lay supine and unconscious on the grass at FedEx Field with his teammates and opposing players standing hushed around him, Westbrook's arms were extended rigidly at his sides, locked in the grip of the event that had just leveled him.

The presence of such a reaction indicated a severe medical emergency, one that can be caused by a stroke, brain hemorrhage, a tumor, or some other traumatic brain injury. In the case of Westbrook - who is expected to play today for the first time since that moment - it was caused by his choice of profession, which led to a violent collision between his helmet and the right knee of Washington Redskins linebacker London Fletcher during a Monday Night Football game nearly three weeks ago.

Story continues below.

As soon as Westbrook was awakened on the field by head trainer Rick Burkholder, nearly the only question asked aloud about the Eagles' running back concerned when he would be able to again play football.

That is normal in his business. Players "get dinged" or "get their bell rung," and it is considered part of the job. Westbrook suffered what is commonly called a concussion, in this instance a blow severe enough to put him to sleep. It might be normal for pro football, but it is decidedly not normal.

"When your lights go out after taking a hit, something really bad happened in your head," said Douglas H. Smith, the director of the Penn Center for Brain Injury and Repair. "It has to be something bad to make you go off-line like that."

Smith, a doctor and a professor of neurosurgery at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, is a leading researcher in the correlation between traumatic brain injuries, which include concussions, and their long-term effects on the victims.

"What happens in some cases looks like Alzheimer's disease in people who have had repeated concussions," Smith said. "This is what our group studies, and it appears that when you damage the nerve fibers in the brain, the ongoing changes last for years and can ultimately manifest themselves that way."

The House Judiciary Committee brought representatives of the NFL into hearings last month to ask about this kind of thing and to inquire what the league intended to do about it. There were horror stories of the cumulative brain injuries that have plagued former players, of once vital men who couldn't hold jobs, who drifted into homelessness, who, as in the case of former Eagles safety Andre Waters, took their own lives.

1 | 2 | 3 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|