City pension-fund shortfall comes to $5B ... & counting

March 01, 2010|By BOB WARNER, warnerb@phillynews.com 215-854-5885

AFTER $1 BILLION in investment losses, Philadelphia's municipal pension fund has sunk into its biggest hole yet - about $5 billion short of the assets it should be holding to pay future retirement benefits to thousands of city employees.

An actuarial report prepared for the city pension board says that the system's assets, valued at $4 billion in mid-2009, amounted to just 45 percent of its liabilities - significantly weaker than the pension funds in most of the nation's big cities.

The deficit will force city taxpayers to come up with $1.7 billion for the pension system over the next three years - more than $1,000 for every man, woman and child in Philadelphia, according to projections that the city has put into its five-year financial plan.

City Finance Director Rob Dubow describes the escalating pension costs as "perhaps the biggest financial challenge we face."

They also could lead to a fight between the Nutter administration and municipal unions over reducing pension benefits for future employees.

A new five-year contract with the city's police officers, awarded by arbitrators in December, allows the city to set up a new pension program for new police hires. It will require them to contribute more toward their own retirements and allow them to enroll in a hybrid program with a 401(k) component.

Another arbitration panel is considering a new contract for firefighters. But no progress has been made on pensions or other issues between the Nutter administration and the two unions representing nonuniformed workers, whose contracts expired last summer.

Because of the 2008 stock-market crash, the market value of the pension fund's assets declined more than $1 billion from mid-2008 to mid-2009.

But the overall problem goes back to the 1950s, when the city increased pension benefits with little attention to their ultimate costs, and unfunded liabilities merited only a footnote in the pension system's annual reports.

Since then, it has grown into one of the city's biggest financial sinkholes, as one mayor after another has left a bigger pension hole for his successor, kicking the problem down the road to future taxpayers.

Politicians who run for office every two or four years are usually inclined to ignore issues like climate change and pension reform, where it may take decades to see the consequences.

1 | 2 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|