Tackling hits and misses of Eagles' drafts

April 22, 2010|By ED BARKOWITZ, barkowe@phillynews.com
Image 1 of 2
  • Freddie Mitchell never lived up to his own hype.
  • Freddie Mitchell never lived up to his own hype.
  • Linebacker Seth Joyner was an eighth-round pick in 1986.

IN HONOR of the 75th anniversary of the NFL draft, here is a look at some of the Eagles' all-time best grabs and worst gaffes.

Who knows? The Eagles could add some guys tonight when this is compiled in another 75 years. Check back in 2085.

 

THE STUDS

10. Seth Joyner, LB, 1986

8th round, 208th overall

Tremendous value for an outside linebacker of some great Eagles defenses. The Eagles took Clyde Simmons in the ninth round. Not a bad haul.

9. Pete Pihos, E, 1945

5th round, 41st overall

Pihos became a six-time Pro Bowler and caught the winning touchdown in the 1949 championship game.

Story continues below.

8. Brian Dawkins, S, 1996

2nd round, 61st overall

A future Hall of Famer, B-Dawk appeared in seven Pro Bowls in his 13-year career as an Eagle and is one of the most beloved Birds of all time. The Eagles had two picks in that 1996 second round. Jason Dunn (54th overall) was the other.

7. Tommy McDonald, B, 1957

3rd round, 31st overall

Played seven seasons for the Eagles and caught 13 touchdowns in 1960, the last time the Birds won the NFL title. When McDonald retired in 1968, he was sixth all-time in receptions, fourth in receiving yards and second in TDs.

6. Harold Carmichael, WR, 1971

7th round, 161st overall

Pretty good value for a guy who ended up as the franchise's all-time leader in receptions (589), yards (8,978) and touchdown catches (79). Mel Gray, who ended up playing for the Cardinals for 12 years, was a sixth-round pick.

5. Steve Van Buren, B, 1944

1st round, 5th overall

Won the NFL rushing title four times and was the offensive leader of the 1948 and 1949 NFL title teams. The 205 yards he ran for against Pittsburgh in 1949 remain a team record. Van Buren was named a member of the NFL's 75th anniversary team in 1994.

4. Wilbert Montgomery, RB, 1977

6th round, 154th overall

The Eagles traded their picks in the first four rounds and still ended up with Montgomery, the team's all-time leading rusher. Ran for 194 yards in the NFC Championship Game against Dallas to send the Eagles to the Super Bowl that followed the 1980 season.

3. Donovan McNabb, QB, 1999

1st round, 2nd overall

Quarterbacks were supposed to be the strength of the 1999 draft, but the Eagles picked the only one who really amounted to anything. He never won a championship, but McNabb was the face of the franchise during its greatest time of sustained success.

2. Brian Westbrook, RB, 2002

3rd round, 91st overall

1 | 2 | 3 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|