But municipalities had been trimming spending even before that. According to the state Civil Service Commission, 1,908 positions have been targeted for elimination this year by municipalities, counties, fire departments, libraries, and commissions in the civil service system, which includes about a third of towns in New Jersey. (The number of positions eliminated could be smaller if towns change their minds after notifying the state.) That figure is nearly twice the number that were targeted for elimination in all of 2009.