Unsentimental Eagles play no favorites when cutting players

July 24, 2010|By Mike Jensen and Ashley Fox, Inquirer Staff Writers
Image 1 of 7
  • Brian Dawkins signing autographs at the Eagles' 2006 preseason camp. Fans were unhappy with the decision to let him become a free agent.
  • Brian Dawkins signing autographs at the Eagles' 2006 preseason camp. Fans were unhappy with the decision to let him become a free agent.
  • Eagles defensive backs Lito Sheppard (left) and Asante Samuel at a 2008 minicamp. Former teammate Sheldon Brown says that he and Sheppard knew that the time to leave would come, after seeing players such as Brian Dawkins and Troy Vincent go.
  • Ex-Eagle Sheldon Brown said that if the team "cared about what the city cared about them, they wouldn't be as successful as they are."
  • Troy Vincent holding court in the Eagles' locker room at the Vet in 2001. The team says it weighs leadership when making decisions.
  • Jon Runyan, a former Eagle, knows injuries can be a factor in a team's decisions.

Seventh of an eight-part series

Some are role players passing through. Others become all-pros. The chosen few become folk heroes.

But all Eagles players have one thing in common - eventually, they become ex-Eagles, even if most never see it coming.

The end game for a professional football player is harsh. For years they give their bodies, and often their minds, to a franchise. Yes, they do it for a paycheck, but they also presumably do it for the common goal - to have success, to win a championship, to hoist the silver Lombardi Trophy.

When it's over, it's over quickly. The Eagles' management team is many things, but emotional is not one. They leave that to the fans.

Story continues below.

"I'm actually proud of the fact that we've always put, at least in our judgment, what gave us the best chance to win ahead of maybe what looked the best or what was safest," said Eagles president Joe Banner.

Inside the NovaCare Complex, endless film study and analytical debate are devoted to the Eagles' own roster. Every assistant coach writes up detailed postseason reports on each player under his supervision. Coordinators add their own detailed reports. General manager Howie Roseman writes up his evaluations after each game and looks back at them after the season. In the NFL, injuries typically aren't used as mitigating factors in a player's favor. They are more likely to be a reason for dismissal.

In the NFL, personnel decisions obviously are about value. Eagles head coach Andy Reid has to make hard calls on which players have lost a step. Banner is asking hard questions about the proper length of the next contract.

"You don't want to get into a situation where a lot of teams have, to go back to ground zero and start from scratch and come back up," Roseman said. "We've always thought we could retool this on the fly. Find guys that we thought maybe didn't have a lot of time left, and replace them with guys that kind of fill similar roles - good players. Do that instead of taking a year on the chin."

 

End comes quickly

Think about recent Eagles rosters. How many former starters have hung on as backups? It's not the way the franchise does business. Backup roles are for the up-and-comers, with a rare spot saved for a special-teams ace such as former Eagles linebacker Ike Reese. If Eagles players often take their time getting to the top of the mountain, there is no gentle descent.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|