Ellen Gray: On 3 new TV series, 'Breakthrough with Tony Robbins,' 'MasterChef' and 'Plain Jane,' change is the goal

July 27, 2010
Image 1 of 2
  • Gordon Ramsay (left) is a judge on "MasterChef," a new Fox show. Tony Robbins' (right) new series is "Breakthrough," on NBC.
  • Gordon Ramsay (left) is a judge on "MasterChef," a new Fox show. Tony Robbins' (right) new series is "Breakthrough," on NBC.

BREAKTHROUGH WITH TONY ROBBINS. 8 tonight, Channel 10.

MASTERCHEF. 9 tonight, Channel 29.

PLAIN JANE. 9 p.m. tomorrow, Channel 57.

TRANSFORMATION'S THE name of the game for three new "reality" shows that feature people who won't be singing, dancing or - we can only hope - turning over tables in their quest to become happier, more successful human beings.

What could possibly be wrong with that?

Let's just say there are two kinds of people in the world: Those willing to pay to be inspired by motivational speakers and those who'd rather cross hot coals barefoot than spend even one minute trapped in a crowded ballroom listening to one.

Story continues below.

Falling as I do in the latter camp, I'm probably not the best judge of NBC's "Breakthrough with Tony Robbins," which struck me as way more Tony Robbins than breakthrough.

Certainly it's hardly one for NBC, whose increasing reliance on "The Biggest Loser" - and its annoying offspring, "Losing It with Jillian" - suggests an ambition to transform itself into a basic-cable channel.

In the two episodes I've seen, "Breakthrough" features couples with problems even bigger than the 6-foot-7 Robbins being subjected to a series of high-adrenaline "challenges" meant to show them they're capable of more than they think.

Whether they're visiting Robbins at his home in Fiji - yes, he has a home in Fiji - or at some setting in Malibu, Calif., they're taken out of their day-to-day lives for these exercises, each of which are meant to illustrate some maxim of Robbins'.

While none of what he's saying feels particularly original, I wouldn't call it terrible advice - more like common sense, forcefully delivered.

But like "Loser," "Breakthrough" comes with made-for-TV drama (including the use of some expensive-looking airplanes) that may not be so easily translated into change for most of the people watching, especially in next week's episode, which features an unemployed couple whose happy ending requires a certain amount of string-pulling on Robbins' part.

Happy endings come in all flavors, and in Fox's "MasterChef," the opportunity for an amateur cook to be declared a "master chef" by judges Gordon Ramsay ("Hell's Kitchen"), Joe Bastianich and Graham Elliott comes with a $250,000 prize and the publication of a cookbook.

So look for anyone whose friends or family ever told them they were good in the kitchen to show up and try to prove it.

1 | 2 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|