It was the second time in a week, that the use of President Obama's image in a carnival game has caused a stir.
Players have been paying $5 for a bucket of balls to throw them at plates held by the characters in the arcade's "Walkin Charlie" game.
Other figures include likenesses of Osama Bin Laden, Michael Jackson, a nameless Red Sox player and Stewie from the animated TV series Family Guy.
Tom Whalen, 59, said he didn't mean to offend anyone by adding Obama to the game a month ago. It's all for fun, he said.
"Heck, I voted for the son of a gun," said Whalen. "But I'm not real happy with some of the things going on with the health care issue."
Last week, a carnival operator in the Lehigh Valley removed a game in which players shot darts at an image of Obama.
Irvin Good Jr. received a complaint from a Massachusetts woman attending a fair in Roseto, about 20 miles north of Bethlehem, Pa. Good said his company, Hellertown-based Goodtime Amusements, will not offer the game again.
"It was just a big, big mistake in judgment, and I feel sorry about it," Good said.
Whalen said he's commissioned figures, of Hillary Clinton and Sarah Palin and also is planning to include 'Snooki' and "'Situation' from Jersey Shore.