BP told to retrieve failed device as evidence

August 20, 2010|By Mark Seibel, McClatchy Newspapers
  • Thad Allen , briefing reporters in Washington, said, "We are concerned about preserving evidence." That will push back the date for completion of a relief well.

WASHINGTON - The Obama administration on Thursday ordered BP to remove the failed blowout preventer from its Deepwater Horizon well in the Gulf of Mexico and preserve it as possible evidence in civil and criminal investigations.

Retired Coast Guard Adm. Thad Allen issued the instruction after a week of what he called "intense negotiation" between BP and government scientists over how to proceed with completing a relief well that BP began drilling May 2.

Allen, who is leading the spill effort for the Obama administration, has called the relief well the only way to be certain that the BP well is dead.

Story continues below.

Previously, he had predicted that the relief well would be completed this week. Initially this week he declined to set a firm date. On Thursday, Allen said the new instruction would push back the date to sometime after Sept. 6.

"We do not want to have damage to the blowout preventer," he said in explaining the delay. "We are concerned about preserving evidence."

Why the blowout preventer - a giant collection of valves designed to sever a deepwater well's drilling pipe in the event of an emergency - did not work has been a key question for investigators probing the April 20 explosion that killed 11 oil-rig workers and sparked a gusher that caused billions of dollars in economic damage along the Gulf Coast.

Other questions

BP officials told Congress in May that diagrams they had of the blowout preventer were inaccurate and that they wasted days trying to activate its shearing mechanisms.

Other reports have raised questions about the way the device was modified and maintained, including a failure to repair a hydraulic leak that may have undermined its ability to shear through the drill pipe.

The blowout preventer actually is owned by Transocean, the company from which BP had leased the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig. BP and Transocean have blamed each other for the device's failure to seal the well, and the two appear likely to face off in court over how much each should pay out for the tragedy.

In a sternly worded letter to BP's lawyers, Transocean has accused the oil giant of withholding documents key to pinpointing the cause of the accident, the Associated Press reported.

BP spokeswoman Elizabeth Ashford said Transocean's accusations were misleading and misguided.

1 | 2 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|