Because the contemporary-ballet troupe's work was more "stylized movement" than dance, May says, he could perform despite having had a spinal fusion in 1993. But pain that eventually led to a hip replacement in 2007 forced him to stop dancing.
"That's when I decided to go back to writing music full time and doing it seriously," he says.
For his first two albums, Once Was Red and Fate Said Nevermind, May collaborated with local producer and multi-instrumentalist Anthony Newett and songwriters such as Stephen Patti and Jerry Guerra. The 2006 debut, featuring "Lights Out in Tupelo," got airplay from WXPN-FM.