DRPA Chairman John Estey led the opposition to the proposal, saying he believed it would prompt "a mass exodus of our professional staff and hamstring our ability to recruit staff."
Estey was joined in voting "no" by Pennsylvania board members Robert Bogle, Robin Wiessmann, and Frank DiCicco. Since a majority of each state's eight-member delegation is required for passage, the proposal failed.
At the meeting, there was a verbal dustup between Dougherty and two top-ranking DRPA staffers when Dougherty asked about rumors that a DRPA police officer had been prevented from "doing his job" in an unspecified encounter.