Lady Antebellum's Grammy upset? Blame it on Nixon

February 15, 2011|By Dan DeLuca, Inquirer Music Critic
Image 1 of 2
  • Grammy-upset Lady Antebellum - Charles Kelley, Hillary Scott, and Dave Haywood. Experts predicted Eminem, Cee Lo Green.
  • Grammy-upset Lady Antebellum - Charles Kelley, Hillary Scott, and Dave Haywood. Experts predicted Eminem, Cee Lo Green.
  • Soul singer Cee Lo Green, in psychedelic-Mummer garb at the Grammys, was expected to win for his profane pop hit.

So: Lady Antebellum wins five Grammys and sends Eminem home scowling with only two. How did that happen?

Here's how: Lady Antebellum is the Nixonland candidate; part of the not-so-silent majority; this year's stealth Taylor Swift; the voice of Middle America with a pretty, de-twanged sound that's all about harking back to a "simpler" time.

How far back? Well, the Nashville country-pop trio's name evokes nostalgia for a pre-Civil War, Gone With the Wind era, with romantic images of Rhett Butler and Scarlett O'Hara, white-columned plantation houses, and, oh yeah, black slaves laboring in the cotton fields.

I don't mean to demonize the band. I'm sure they're nice people. But, really, I hate their name.

Story continues below.

So how did they win all those awards, when supposed experts like myself predicted that it was obviously Eminem's year and that maybe Cee Lo Green's fantastic (and profane) pop song would get a little somethin'-somethin' besides?

Easily. The Grammys like to think of themselves as daring and edgy, more Gaga than Antebellum, when it comes to their choice of Ladies. But while media attention was paid to Eminem's impressive comeback and Cee Lo's pop hit - referred to on the Grammys as "the song otherwise known as 'Forget You' " - something got lost in the shuffle. East and West Coasters who wouldn't be caught dead listening to country radio wouldn't know it, but the album that led in sales for most of 2010 was Lady A's Need You Now. It ultimately sold 3.09 million copies, second only to Eminem's Recovery, which sold 3.42 million.

Lady A is being referred to as a "country-crossover" act in a lot of places. But that's not nearly as true for them this year as it was in 2010 for Swift, who was that year's big country-pop Grammy winner. Swift has an omnipresent, mainstream-pop, girl-next-door profile, but Lady A is largely a phenomenon of country radio.

If you stubbornly insist on thinking that "country" means Dolly Parton and Merle Haggard more than Kenny Chesney and Sugarland, then you probably don't think Nashville slickers like Lady A have any business pretending to be part of the Hank Williams-Patsy Cline legacy.

1 | 2 | 3 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|