Birthright of illegal residents' children is under attack

March 04, 2011|By Michael Matza, Inquirer Staff Writer
Image 1 of 2
  • Obstetrician Jack Ludmir founded a prenatal clinic for immigrant women. He does not ask their immigration status, but estimates that at least 14 percent of the women who deliver there are in the United States illegally.
  • Obstetrician Jack Ludmir founded a prenatal clinic for immigrant women. He does not ask their immigration status, but estimates that at least 14 percent of the women who deliver there are in the United States illegally.
  • "I am not a politician," Dr. Jack Ludmir said. "I am not here to argue that the borders should be tighter. That is not my fight."

Twelve years ago, Lizbeth Ramos and her common-law husband, Juan, left their hometown near Puebla, Mexico, and set out on foot across the desert for the Arizona border, to slip into new lives as illegal immigrants.

He found work in a produce market in the Philadelphia area, she in a boutique. They saved up to start a family.

Now 30, she lies on an examination table in Pennsylvania Hospital, at a weekly obstetrics clinic for immigrant women, no status questions asked. As a doctor slides an ultrasound wand over her bulging belly, her eyes are transfixed by the monitor. She is carrying twins.

Story continues below.

The moment they enter the world, they will be what their parents are not: U.S. citizens.

Such is their birthright, granted by the 14th Amendment to an estimated 340,000 babies born annually to undocumented immigrants.

But in the marathon fight over immigration control, that 143-year-old constitutional guarantee has become the latest target and the delivery room the new front. The pejorative anchor babies already is in the lexicon.

"Once a child is born here, the parents make the argument that they should be allowed to stay as that child's guardian. They are using that child as an anchor [to] play on our heartstrings," said Pennsylvania Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, a Butler County Republican who has built a national reputation as a crusader against what he calls "illegal alien invaders."

Immigrant advocates dismiss his contention as myth, and point to a recent study that found that undocumented immigrants generally "come for work and to join family members." The Washington-based nonprofit Immigration Policy Center concluded that "they do not come specifically to give birth" and game the immigration system.

Such assertions have not tempered efforts by immigration-control proponents to effectively do away with "birthright citizenship" for illegal immigrants' children.

On the federal level, two Republican senators, David Vitter of Louisiana and Rand Paul of Kentucky, want to accomplish it by amending the Constitution to allow automatic citizenship only if a child has at least one parent who is a citizen, a legal permanent resident, or an active-duty soldier.

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|