Play about real funny guys elicits only grins

Posted: April 15, 2011

Laughter on the 23rd Floor, Neil Simon's nostalgic valentine to Sid Caesar's early-TV variety program Your Show of Shows, provides an entertaining evening in 1812's accomplished production at Plays & Players. The show's comedy writers - a who's who of successful funnymen - worked in NBC's offices back in the 1950s, cranking out 90 minutes of live television every week.

Among the gang in the Writer's Room during this Golden Age was, of course, the playwright, a young Neil Simon (later to write some of Broadway's most successful shows), as well as Larry Gelbart (M*A*S*H, Tootsie, etc.), Carl Reiner (The Dick Van Dyke Show, etc.), Mel Brooks (The 2000-Year-Old Man, Blazing Saddles, etc.), Woody Allen (well, you know), Selma Diamond (My Favorite Year), Aaron Ruben (Sanford and Son, etc.), Gary Belkin (The Carol Burnett Show, etc).

King of this hilarious mountain and star of the show was Sid Caesar, a notorious wild man, a pill-popping drunk, a passionate liberal who occasionally put his fist through walls (the holes then framed in silver on the Wall of Terror), here played by the excellent Pete Pryor. The writers are Mike Doherty, David Ingram, Carl Wallnau, Anthony Lawton, Jennifer Childs, Dave Jadico, and Chris Faith (with a very funny Russian accent). Kelly Vrooman is the secretary who fills their bizarre requests unblinkingly. Corralling this gang is director Matt Pfeiffer.

There is the inevitable daunting element: As soon as you write a show about the funniest writers in the business, they have to be funny. And they are, but maybe not quite funny enough; Laughter on the 23rd Floor makes you smile rather than fall off your chair. There is enough history woven through the script to teach us something about the 1950s in TV (would there have been a Jon Stewart or Stephen Colbert without Sid Caesar?) and about the country (the McCarthy hearings). "All humor is based on hostility," says somebody. "That's why World War II was so funny," says somebody else. Ba-da-bum.

Stalin dies, McCarthy is censured, NBC cancels the show. Time goes by, and now we have a zillion channels.


Laughter on the 23rd Floor

Presented by 1812 Productions at Plays & Players Theatre, 1714 Delancey Place. Through May 15. Tickets $20-$35. Information: 215-592-9560 or www.1812Productions.org.


|
|
|
|
|