Mobs disrupt an urban oasis

August 05, 2011

By Elijah Anderson

Flash mobs have reappeared on the streets of Center City. These groups of mostly black youths gravitate to a designated location at an appointed time. Once there, they become a mob that gathers force as it roams the streets, wreaking havoc on businesses while terrifying and sometimes attacking pedestrians.

As quickly as these storms appear, they're over. But the effects are lasting, powerfully rending the diverse, civil public spaces we might call cosmopolitan canopies.

Historically, despite William Penn's vision of a City of Brotherly Love that accepts all kinds of people, most Philadelphians have lived in racial and ethnic enclaves. This segregation persists today.

Story continues below.

Yet Center City is dotted with cosmopolitan canopies such as the Reading Terminal Market and Rittenhouse Square. These are usually calm and relatively pleasant places where a diverse mix of people go about their business, at times self-consciously on good "downtown" behavior. They come to "know" each other without having met, and they can be helpful to complete strangers. Such settings, which no one group expressly owns but which all are encouraged to share - situated under a protective umbrella, or canopy - are a special type of urban space that every visitor seems to recognize, appreciate, and enjoy.

The canopy allows people who identify strongly with class or ethnic groups to work toward a more cosmopolitan appreciation of difference. They discover people who are strangers not just as individuals, but also as representatives of other groups. The canopy can thus be a profoundly humanizing experience.

As canopies proliferate, their qualities become elements of the city. The resulting social sophistication helps diverse people get along.

After violent incidents such as the recent flash mobs, the canopy must recover its reputation as an oasis of comity. Media coverage of these events is unrelenting. As a result, young black men become more defined as people to fear, even though the mobs may be sprinkled with whites. People warily watch for those who might engage in this sort of activity; the figures that readily come to mind are young, black, and male.

1 | 2 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|