Cops: No sex charges against jail guard accused by transgender inmate

September 24, 2011|BY DANA DiFILIPPO, difilid@phillynews.com 215-854-5934
Image 1 of 2
  • Jabreena Barnett describes facial hair on Saldana, her cellmate of five weeks. She has filed a claim against Saldana and the city alleging violation of her privacy.    
  • Jabreena Barnett describes facial hair on Saldana, her cellmate of five weeks. She has filed a claim against Saldana and the city alleging violation of her privacy.     (ALEJANDRO A. ALVAREZ / STAFF…)
  • Jovanie Saldana, in family photo, blurred at their request, has been transferred to a men's jail. (.   FAMILY…)

A CITY CORRECTIONAL officer who had been accused of sexual assault by a transgender inmate will not be criminally charged, police confirmed yesterday.

The officer also had a disciplinary hearing Thursday, but Prisons Commissioner Louis Giorla hasn't acted on the hearing's recommendations yet, spokeswoman Shawn Hawes said.

The inmate's allegation, made last month, sparked scrutiny of security procedures at Riverside, the city's female jail, because officials learned that the inmate, Jovanie Saldana, spent 14 months there despite having male genitalia. Prison policy requires inmates to be housed by "anatomical gender" regardless of how they identify, meaning that Saldana - who had long hair, arched eyebrows and cleavage when arrested in June 2010 - should have been jailed in a male facility.

Story continues below.

Authorities discovered the goof when they investigated Saldana's claim that a male correctional officer forced Saldana to perform oral sex on him. Police spokeswoman Officer Christine O'Brien said yesterday that detectives closed their investigation into that claim this week without charging the correctional officer. She didn't have details on the case, and Capt. John Darby, commander of the Special Victims Unit, couldn't be reached for comment.

Saldana, 23, now is being housed in a male jail separate from the general population, awaiting trial on Oct. 31 in an unrelated aggravated assault case.

That no one noticed Saldana's genitalia, despite multiple strip searches and at least two medical exams, concerned prison officials, who noted that thorough strip and cavity searches are the prison system's primary weapons against contraband.

While the case cost officials embarrassment and headaches, it soon could cost taxpayers money.

Jabreena Barnett, a female inmate who shared a cell with Saldana for five weeks, has filed a claim against the city seeking unspecified damages, alleging that Saldana and city officials violated her civil rights and privacy by forcing her to live with a man.

Barnett, 34, said she told several correctional officers of her doubts about Saldana's anatomical gender but never filed a formal complaint.

"There was definitely something off - she had big calves, broad shoulders, no butt - but she had a lot of feminine ways," Barnett said, adding that Saldana hid behind a chair when using the toilet and wore undergarments to the shower.

Barnett accused Saldana of grabbing her breasts to express admiration for them, a claim her attorney said demonstrates sexual harassment and unwanted touching.

"I find it hard to believe, no matter what kind of magician you are, unless this person had a sex change, that somebody didn't know about this," her attorney Brian Humble said.

|
|
|
|
|