Sunday, Bloody Sunday

NFL has become new Roman Coliseum

October 02, 2011|By John Smallwood
Image 1 of 6
  • Wait a minute, says Michael Vick, I'm getting hit too much. (Yong Kim/Staff Photographer)
  • Wait a minute, says Michael Vick, I'm getting hit too much. (Yong Kim/Staff Photographer)
  • Michael Vick will likely take the field when the Eagles host the 49ers on Sunday, sources say. (AP Photo)
  • Eagles fan witnessed a 29-16 Eagles loss to the Giants in the home opener. (David Maialetti/Staff Photographer)
  • Michael Vick gets hit by the Giants' Kenny Phillips and Antrel Rolle during the third quarter. (Ron Cortes/Staff Photographer)
  • Michael Vick injured his right hand during Sunday's loss to the Giants. (Yong Kim/Staff Photographer)
  • Michael Vick reacts to a false start penalty against the Eagles. (David Maialetti/Staff Photographer)

IN THE short term, Michael Vick might get what he wants.

His complaints about officials not affording him the same protective considerations that go to such quarterbacks as Tom Brady, Peyton Manning or Drew Brees may very well result in a few more yellow flags when Vick gets steamrolled by a defensive end after throwing from the pocket.

But a 15-yard penalty isn't going to solve the bigger issue.

A call from an official would not have prevented Vick from injuring his hand when he was hit by New York Giants defensive end Chris Canty.

An unnecessary-roughness call and a fine levied against Atlanta Falcons cornerback Dunta Robinson didn't take back the concussion that Eagles receiver DeSean Jackson got last season.

Story continues below.

Penalties and fines are after-the-fact measures.

They can only act as deterrents.

The NFL's effort to legislate safety into the sport is a lost cause. It cannot be done.

"There are certain things you can do, like make certain types of hits illegal," Eagles receiver Jason Avant said. "You can teach guys not to shoot with their helmets.

"But a lot of it is just part of the game. It's human nature and we've been playing football like this for so long. Certain things you just can't control."

If we are honest with ourselves, we don't want them controlled.

The physical nature of the NFL is a primary attraction.

We want to see the bone-jarring hits. During the course of a game, they get as a big a cheer as a touchdown.

And, yes, we even want to see guys get hurt, not injured, but definitely beat up, battered and bruised.

Everyone knows the deal.

NFL players are paid to sacrifice their bodies and health for our entertainment.

Each Sunday they risk life-altering injury so we can release a week's worth of stress and frustration vicariously through them.

It's our Roman Coliseum. We love the gladiator-like combat. It sells because it is brutal.

The NFL can put out whatever public-relations spin it wants to show that it is concerned about player safety, but ultimately, football is what it is.

At its core, it is the same game that President Theodore Roosevelt threatened to ban in 1905 because of 19 player deaths.

It is violent, and everyone accepts what that involves.

The entire culture of football is in direct opposition to the NFL's efforts to make the game safer.

Vick complains about not being protected and instead of being praised for raising a legitimate player-safety issue, he is ridiculed.

1 | 2 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|