Chaput and the 16-member Blue Ribbon Commission are expected to announce the closings Jan. 6, Three Kings Day.
"The whole situation is absolutely . . . I can't think of the word," said Teresa Hooten, a physics teacher at Little Flower High School who is reliving a nightmare. She taught at Cardinal Dougherty High School until it was shuttered by the Archdiocese last year.
"We are engulfed in anticipation, anxiousness, fear. It's overwhelming. We just want to know," Hooten said.
"It's absolutely ruining Christmas. It would have been kinder to tell us now."
While waiting for an announcement, area Catholics have been busy filling the information vacuum. They speculate about which schools are on "the list." They wonder what alternatives will be left.
Inadvertently, local Catholics have become players in a game of "whisper down the lane."
"You hear all kinds of rumors about what they're doing," said Rita Schwartz, president of the Association of Catholic Teachers.
"Whispering down the lane becomes so convoluted after five people. Rumors are not the best thing. But if all you have are rumors, it's all you can talk about."
Teachers' conversations at lunchtime have "intensified" since Chaput last weekend released a letter - considered by many to be unprecedented in the Archdiocese in its bluntness - that laid out the school-closings issue.
The Blue Ribbon Commission, Chaput wrote, "will likely counsel that some, and perhaps many, schools must close or combine."
"It was so depressing," Hooten said, describing it as a "punch in the stomach."
Hooten, Schwartz and others are concerned for all the students and teachers who must leave schools set for closure, but they are particularly sympathetic to those who have experienced closure before.
Some Dougherty students transferred to Bishop McDevitt High School, one of the schools rumored to be closing, Hooten said.
John Marquess, a North Catholic graduate whose alma mater was closed by the Archdiocese last year, said he can't imagine how families can endure two closures in two years.
"Twice in two years they're going to be told, 'Never mind. You're on your own again.' I don't know how as a parent you weather this. I don't know how the administration is going to handle this," said Marquess, a lawyer in Cherry Hill. "I think a lot of the parents are going to say, 'Although I want a Catholic education for my son, I can't do this to my son again.'"
The closure rumors appear to be getting to Chaput, too, even though he's been in Philadelphia only since September.
"I am VERY irritated by this campaign," he reportedly wrote to a West Catholic alum who sent him an email along with a slew of others lobbying to save the school.
"It clogs up my computer and makes it difficult for me to communicate with others" Chaput wrote. "I am tempted to remove my email from the public because of things like this . . . These campaigns are really counterproductive."