The restrictions are most likely to affect people without a driver's license - generally the poor, young, and old. They will be forced to jump through time-consuming and potentially costly hoops to keep their right to vote, all to solve a problem that hardly seems to exist.
Incoming Philadelphia City Commissioner Stephanie Singer made that point recently in decrying Republican efforts to pass similar restrictions in the Pennsylvania legislature. Singer's job is to promote widespread, informed, and honest participation in elections, and unlike many of her predecessors in the office, she seems to be taking it seriously.
In South Carolina, with a history of legalized discrimination and many poor minority voters, the new requirement would wrongly discourage the exercise of the most fundamental right in our democracy. Pennsylvania is not covered by all the provisions of the 1965 Voting Rights Act, but the Justice Department's move lends support to Pennsylvanians, like Singer, who are opposing such restrictions here.
Though their details vary from state to state, voter ID laws all tend to discourage a certain type of voter from showing up on Election Day. It's no coincidence that these new burdens on young and disadvantaged voters, who generally lean Democratic, are being imposed by state governments controlled by Republicans. And it's no coincidence that the Voting Rights Act is under attack by conservative judicial activists, who want the Supreme Court to strike it down.
The court gave carte blanche to burdensome voter ID requirements in a 2008 case from Indiana. It did so even though Indiana, like South Carolina, could not document a single case of voter impersonation, and the new rules immediately disenfranchised at least 40,000 eligible voters. In Pennsylvania, as many as 700,000 could be stripped of their voting rights if legislators proceed with a similar measure.
In a nation where only about half the eligible population shows up for presidential elections, our leaders should be doing all they can to encourage voting, not making it harder.