N.J. gets a D-plus for teacher standards

A national study ranked training and evaluation, not the overall quality of the educational process.

January 25, 2012|By Geoff Mulvihill, Associated Press
  • New Jersey Governor Chris Christie speaks at the Lanning Square School in South Camden on Jan. 12, after signing a bill that allows private firms to run failing public schools in three inner-city districts.

New Jersey's report card from a group that seeks to improve standards for educators is dismal: D-plus, 36th in the United States, and making less progress than most states.

The report, scheduled to be published Wednesday by the National Council on Teacher Quality, could bolster parts of Gov. Christie's education-overhaul agenda - though the governor's critics say it shouldn't.

The analysis considers how teachers are trained, evaluated, rewarded, and fired.

But it does not assess the overall state of teaching and learning. That's an area where, on average, New Jersey is among the highest-performing states - despite being home to low-performing schools, particularly in its most impoverished cities.

Some of the areas Christie wants to fix are the same ones the Washington-based research and policy group says are broken.

"What the governor has proposed with evaluation and tenure would put New Jersey among the trailblazer states," said Sandi Jacobs, the council's vice president.

New Jersey's grade barely budged from the D it received from the group two years ago. Florida, where standardized test scores fall far short of New Jersey's, received the highest mark this year - and it got just a B.

Jacobs said several states are revising - or, like New Jersey, considering changing - how teachers are evaluated and granted tenure, upending long-standing job-security provisions. But few states have made much progress on raising requirements for teacher-education programs at colleges, she said.

Finding ways to make teachers more accountable for how well students perform has been a major trend in education policy debates in Washington and in many states, including New Jersey.

Christie wants half of teacher evaluations based on measures of student performance - including standardized tests and other measures that districts can choose. And he wants the evaluations to have consequences, including merit-based pay raises for top teachers and loss of tenure protections for those who repeatedly get low marks.

The governor also wants districts to be able to get rid of low-performing teachers, rather than the last ones hired, in the event of layoffs.

1 | 2 | Next »
|
|
|
|
|