Personal Journey: Visit to India offers views of two worlds

February 12, 2012|By Natalie Zellat Dyen, For The Inquirer
  • Bullock carts on a dirt road in Thanjavur, India. The riders stopped to scoop dirt into the carts for use in construction.

When the driver turned left onto the dirt road, we thought he'd made a mistake. On one corner a group of men stood beside a pile of burning trash; on another, women sold fish from a makeshift stall. The travel agent had booked us into a hotel at least two stars above what we had requested in Thanjavur, a temple city in southern India, but this bumpy road couldn't possibly be the right one.

Finally the driver slowed down, and there, on the other side of a metal gate, stood our hotel - an upscale resort with stunning river views, manicured gardens, and a swimming pool. India is a country where poverty and prosperity regularly bump up against each other, and this juxtaposition of dirt road and gated elegance felt like a throwback to colonial times.

Story continues below.

The next morning, I went out early to photograph the sunrise. A worker tending the grounds had just put fresh flowers on a shrine to Ganesh, the elephant god who, it is said, clears obstacles from your path. Fortified by the sense of immunity that some of us naively assume when traveling, I decided to venture out onto the road in search of photo opportunities - but not before giving the elephant's trunk a pat for an extra measure of good luck.

It was quiet on the road - nothing much to see besides trees and scrub. I was about to turn back when I heard shouting in the distance. "Hai. Hai." A pair of bulls pulling a cart emerged in the early morning mist, followed by two other bullock carts. The men standing atop their carts were barefoot and bare-chested; they stopped to scoop dirt into their carts, which were already half full. Later someone told me the dirt was used for construction. In a land where so many have so little, even dirt can be a valuable commodity.

Gauzy sunlight filtering through the trees lent an otherworldly, long-ago quality to the scene, as if I'd passed through a wrinkle in time. Pointing to my camera, I mouthed "OK?" But the men ignored me, so I began snapping, wondering if they had even registered my presence. Once the carts had proceeded into the distance, leaving only a trail of dust to mark their passing, I walked back to the hotel. Slipping through the open gate was like crossing a border between two worlds; it was the kind of border you can find anywhere - Paris, Istanbul, Philadelphia - where the inhabitants of each world are as invisible to the other as the boundaries that separate them.

 


Natalie Zellat Dyen lives in Montgomery County.

|
|
|
|
|