"I'm not a fan at all," Mayock said. "For a big, strong guy, he's nowhere near as strong at the point of attack as I thought he would be."
"[Kuechly's] playmaking and instincts are so good, think about Sean Lee. I think that's the best comparison for him. Sean Lee went in the second round to Dallas [from Penn State, 2 years ago], but has become a Pro Bowl inside linebacker, and I think this kid is very similar. He doesn't have the knee issues Sean had, and I think he's a slightly better athlete," Mayock said.
"If he's not there, I think you've got a little bit of a problem inside," Mayock said. "I don't think Dont'a Hightower, from Alabama, is worthy of the 15th pick in the draft, and I don't think there's any other inside linebackers worthy of that pick."
So what do the Eagles do? Well, if they've gone through free agency, which starts March 13, without really addressing inside linebacking, then maybe they have to trade up several spots to ensure they get Kuechly. Remember, they do have an extra second-round pick to play with. Or, if they get linebacking in free agency, maybe they're looking somewhere else at 15. Mayock sees defensive tackle as the deepest talent group in the first round, with five to seven players to whom he'd assign first-round grades, including Devon Still, from Wilmington and Penn State. Still sat out the Senior Bowl with an ankle problem, but his agent, Drew Rosenhaus, said yesterday that Still will participate fully in next week's NFL Scouting Combine.
Mayock said he had Still at the top of the draft class before he started evaluating junior talent declaring for the draft at DT, and now he thinks maybe there are as many as three better options - Michael Brockers of LSU, Jerel Worthy of Michigan State, and Dontari Poe of Memphis, a raw talent with upside.
The Eagles have to decide by next month whether they are going to pay Cullen Jenkins a $7.5 million roster bonus; seeing how much the Giants' d-line keyed New York's Super Bowl drive might convince them they need more difference-makers up front, particularly inside.
"If both players are equally ranked, then you'd probably want to go defensive tackle first," Mayock said, when asked if the Eagles couldn't get better value at DT than at LB with the 15th pick. "You and I both know the Eagles have struggled with that inside linebacker position for a long time now. I think Kuechly's a special player and I think Kuechly can help solidify what's happening on that defense. He's going to get everybody lined up in the right place, he's going to play well. I think he starts Day 1."