Juliet is played by the lovely Nicole Erb - she looks like a younger Jennifer Garner and has all the shining eagerness of a 14-year-old girl who is wildly, deeply in love. She bounces down steps, moans about "old people," and has intense, tearful tantrums defying her father (Leonard Haas), who wants her to marry handsome Paris (Jake Blouch, who will reappear in a hilarious scene as the illiterate messenger and then again as the ferocious "fashion monger" Tybalt).
Unfortunately, Juliet has fallen in love with Romeo, who is something of a twerp as Shakespeare wrote him, and more of a twerp as Sean Lally plays him. Lally lacks classical diction and has a silly walk (presumably unintentional), detracting from Romeo's tragic stature.
As Mercutio, Charlie DelMarcelle is superb (the Queen Mab speech is splendidly delivered), and as Juliet's nurse Ceal Phelan is both lovable and exasperating, just as she should be. Juliet's mother (K.O. DelMarcelle) seems excessively cold and supercilious, while Frank X as Friar Lawrence is both realistically human and elegantly Shakespearean simultaneously.
The mayhem of the plot, as well as the mayhem of the place, require a fight director, and J. Alex Cordaro does his stuff, with the help of some very able actors who can convincingly fight very close to the audience in the very small arena that is the Lantern's stage. The costumes, designed by Mary Folino, are handsome.
Romeo and Juliet
Presented by Lantern Theater Company at St. Stephen's Theater, 10th and Ludlow Streets, through April 1. Tickets: $20-$36. Information: 215-829-0395 or www.lanterntheater.org.
Follow Toby Zinman on Twitter at #philastage. Read her reviews at www.phillystage.com