On Sunday, Scott Hartnell did it without a second to spare. Hartnell capped the Flyers' hair-raising comeback with 0.9 seconds remaining in overtime - the latest OT winner in franchise history - to deliver a 3-2 win over the fourth-place Penguins.
The Flyers halted Pittsburgh's 11-game winning streak and prevented the Penguins from pulling into a first-place tie with the New York Rangers atop the Atlantic Division.
"We knew they were the hottest team in the NHL," Flyers winger Jaromir Jagr said. "We knew if we were to lose this game, it would be tough to try and come back and finish first. We had to win that game no matter what. [Pittsburgh] gave us that chance."
Now, despite a combined 7-9-3 record against the Rangers, Penguins, Devils, and Bruins this season, the Flyers are just three points behind New York.
But you wouldn't know that based on the way the Flyers played in the first two periods Sunday. They went a total of 18 minutes, 9 seconds - from late in the first period until late in the second - without a single shot on goal.
In fact, a power play with 30 seconds remaining in the second period allowed the Flyers to barely avoid tying a franchise record for fewest shots (1) in a period.
Instead, they used the power play as motivation to start the third period. Up until that point, Ilya Bryzgalov was the only reason they still had a puncher's chance in the final frame. Bryzgalov is 10-2-1 with a 1.69 goals-against average, .941 save percentage, and four shutouts since being pulled against Pittsburgh in the teams' last meeting on Feb. 18.
"He might be [a] quiet [story line] because Hartsy did this and [Sean Couturier] did this, and Kimmo [Timonen] jumps in with that . . . but there were countless big saves after that to keep it from going to 3-0 or 3-1," coach Peter Laviolette said. "You need to get that from your goalie. He gave us a lot of big saves we needed him to make to give us an opportunity to get back in the third."
The Flyers used the wraparound power play to net a goal in the first 31 seconds of the period, when Timonen's blast from the point sneaked over Marc-Andre Fleury's shoulder.
From there, it was a 180-degree change for the Flyers. Defensively, they held Pittsburgh without a shot for 11:32 in the third period and outshot the Penguins, 17-13, in the final period after being crushed, 27-10, over the first two.
"That is the sign of a good team," Timonen said. "You're down, 2-0, against a team who has won 11 in a row, and they've got all their big shots back. And we came back and won the game. That was a playoff atmosphere."
Suddenly, the Flyers have won five games in a row at the Wells Fargo Center. They have 10 games left, seven at home. Two of their three remaining road games are in Pittsburgh, against their most likely playoff opponent.
After this weekend, the Flyers feel as if they can play with the big boys.
"This weekend, we played the Bruins, the Stanley Cup champs," Laviolette said. "They had an attitude because they lost a few games. We battled back and played hard. The Penguins are on a roll. Everybody is talking about their team. I can't say enough about our guys. They didn't cave. That's a great sign from your team, when they don't cave. And that's happened a lot this year."
Contact Frank Seravalli at email@example.com or @DNFlyers on Twitter. Read his blog, Frequent Flyers, at www.philly.com/frequentflyers.