Jury selection begins in Atlantic City murder-kidnapping case

In a 2010 appearance at the Mays Landing courthouse, Craig Arno stood with lawyer Eric Shenkus. APRIL SAUL / Staff Photographer
In a 2010 appearance at the Mays Landing courthouse, Craig Arno stood with lawyer Eric Shenkus. APRIL SAUL / Staff Photographer
Posted: April 05, 2012

MAYS LANDING, N.J. - Jury selection began Wednesday in the murder-kidnapping trial of Craig Arno, accused of stabbing an Atlantic City casino patron to death after abducting him from the garage of the Trump Taj Mahal Hotel Casino in May 2010.

A panel of 150 potential jurors filled out questionnaires in Superior Court here before Judge Michael Donio began individual questioning to determine if they had heard about the case or had prejudices or biases that might prohibit them from serving.

Donio has tentatively set opening arguments for Tuesday.

Arno, 48, faces 28 criminal charges, including murder, arson, kidnapping, carjacking, and robbery. He could be sentenced to life in prison if convicted of homicide.

The Atlantic City resident, who has spent several years in jail on fraud charges, sat quietly through the selection process, which is expected to last several days.

He has been held on $2 million bail since his arrest on May 28, 2010.

The prosecution's case was recently bolstered when Arno's girlfriend and alleged partner in crime pleaded guilty and agreed to testify against him.

At a hearing on Feb. 14, Jessica Kisby, 26, provided a chilling account of the murder of Martin Caballero, 47, a Hudson County grocer who had come to the Taj Mahal on May 21, 2010, to celebrate the birthday of his daughter with family members.

Kisby testified that she and Arno targeted Caballero because he was driving "a nice car."

"We figured he had money," she said.

Caballero was forced into the trunk of his 2009 Lincoln MKS and driven from the garage. Kisby said she and Arno used his credit card to make an ATM withdrawal of about $300.

Later, she said, Arno stabbed Caballero to death. They dumped the body on a dirt road in Hamilton Township, Atlantic County, she said, and drove the Lincoln to Gloucester Township, where they set it on fire.

Kisby said she and Arno never discussed killing Caballero. "It just happened," she said.

Kisby, an Egg Harbor Township resident and single mother of a 7-year-old daughter, will be sentenced to 30 years in prison with no parole under the terms of her plea bargain. She will receive credit for time she has spent in prison since May 2010.

Donio is expected to continue questioning potential jurors on Thursday. The goal is to create a pool of about 50 "qualified" jurors. Twelve jurors and four alternates will be chosen to hear testimony.

The trial is expected to last about five weeks.


Contact staff writer George Anastasia at 856-779-3846 or ganastasia@phillynews.com.

|
|
|
|
|