“We have no beer tradition, which can be hard for marketing,” says Giovanni Campari, 34, the brewmaster and co-owner of five-year-old Birrificio Del Ducato in Parma. “On the other hand, we have not gotten stuck in tradition, either. So we are free to experiment.”
And he’s not kidding. Campari’s Verdi Imperial Stout uses the subtle heat of Calabrian chile peppers to add a little sparkle to the chocolaty richness of the dark beer. Lightly roasted coffee beans (“we are, after all, a coffee culture!”) adds both tastiness and acidity to the brown ale of Caffe Baracco. His Nuova Mattina is a saison-style brewed with ginger, coriander, green peppercorns, lemon balm, and chamomile, an incredibly refreshing brew inspired in equal parts by the Bob Dylan song “New Morning” and his brew-poetic rendition of a fragrant spring field.
“Beer-making is my way to express myself,” says Campari, before heading off to a tasting at Alla Spina, the new Marc Vetri gastropub, with 20 taps and a long Italian beer list, that has quickly become a focal point for the new imports, as well as a destination for visiting brewers.
“As soon as we were able to get our hands on Italian craft beers at this level, we did,” says Steve Wildy, beverage manager of the Vetri group, who began several years ago pairing the first trickle of available beers with tasting menus at the flagship restaurant. He became even more enthusiastic about the possibilities for food pairings after a reconnaissance trip to Rome for Amis. “You can drink these throughout a meal. And you’re a little more likely with Italian beers to find an ‘Ah-hah!’ pairing than with [hops-centric] U.S. or German beers.”
Tria, a. Kitchen, the Farmers' Cabinet, Birra, Stella, and In Riva are among the many other local restaurants that have embraced Italians on their beer list, despite high prices — due to onerous Italian taxes, high production costs, and lack of cost-effective infrastructure — that can make some of these bottles prohibitive, ranging from $8 to $28.
“It’s still in the novelty phase,” says Michael McCaulley, wine director at Tria, which was one of the first Philadelphia bars to serve them. “We’ve had a Birra del Borgo barley wine for $28 that wears its 16 percent alcohol really well and has this cool sour note to it. But how many of those are you going to drink? It’s usually four beer geeks sitting around who want to split a bottle like that.”
More exposure, though, and a spate of recent visits from Italian brewers, has gone a long way to helping Philadelphians understand what goes into these unusual brews. Plus, says Wildy, “the brewers all look like indie rock stars.”
“I may look flamboyant,” concedes Iacopo Lenci, the vividly tattooed and thickly bearded brewmaster-owner of Birrificio Bruton in Tuscany, who could be seen striding up Broad Street recently under several pounds of heavy chains and clanging jewelry. “But I want my beers to be gentle, smooth, elegant.”
And his beers — seriously pricey, large-format bottles — are true to his aim. Brewed with some unusual ingredients (like native Tuscan spelt, which lends a creaminess to the witbier profile of the Bianca) or high alcohol levels (like the deep caramel and licorice-tasting “10” barley wine), they still exhibit remarkable delicacy and balance.
Lenci, 28, in many ways embodies the new generation of Italian craft brewing. The son of a winemaker, Agostino Lenci of Fattoria di Magliano (who, coincidentally, was in town for a wine dinner the same night at Sbraga), Lenci’s beercraft breaks from the Italian wine tradition, but also embraces its food-friendly aesthetic.
“I’m the black sheep of the family,” he says with a grin. “But I would never think about not making beers to pair with food. I’m born to do that. It’s in my Italian DNA.”
The prevailing result is that Italian brewers shy away from the tongue-stripping hops that have become fashionable with American “extreme beer” styles, which Wildy says is “tricky” to pair with food. It has spurred creativity instead of stifled it, as brewers turn to other spices to lend balance and flavors.
“One of the reasons I love these beers is because they’re in experimental mode,” says McCaulley. “The Italians are masters at seasoning beers.”
The use of resinous myrrh in Baladin’s signature brew, Nora, is a prime example that Wildy says lends a piney aroma that’s not as floral as hops. The Ligurian brewer Piccolo Birrificio adds juniper and chinotto peel to its Italian-style saison, Seson, replacing the bitterness of hops with an ingredient more commonly found in Italian bitter cordials such as Campari or Amaro. Even more intriguing, perhaps, are the numerous beers that blend wine- and beer-making (and spirit) techniques into the same bottle, as with the sour and funky BeerBera, a spontaneously fermented ale made with barbera grapes from Birrificio LoverBeer, which ages it in oak barrels, the tannins from which give it extra aging potential.
“This is really a new category,” says Neidhart, referring to a similar beer, Dolii Raptor from Montegioco. “It’s not beer, it’s not wine, it’s not a spirit, but it’s a new kind of alcoholic beverage that draws dimensions from all three categories.”
And though the brewing techniques are largely informed by the Belgian tradition (with some German influence, too), Neidhart says the Italians approach the character of their new passion with a distinctly national flair, rooted much like its cuisine in specific regional flavors and ingredients, from the chestnuts of the north to the herbs and grapes of Sardinia.
Of course, educating a nation of wine drinkers to appreciate such inventive beers is a tall challenge that will take time — which explains why so many Italian brewers have been making the rounds, selling as much as 30 percent of their production for export to savvier markets.
“We Europeans are not very open-minded like you are — especially in Italy, where most people have never tasted an imperial stout,” says Campari. “So we are proud to come and sell our beer here in the U.S., where we can meet people who really appreciate what we do.”
At the pace those beers are landing in local bars, it shouldn’t be long before thirsty Philadelphians have it down: Birrificio? Bravo!
Contact Craig LaBan at 215-854-2682 or firstname.lastname@example.org, or follow on Twitter @CraigLaBan.
Beer tasting notes