And when you have House Majority Leader Mike Turzai boasting that voter ID "is going to allow Governor Romney to win the state of Pennsylvania," you know that passions are going to run high. In fact, this issue sparked the most emotional and difficult discussion we have ever had at the People's Editorial Board — and that includes discussions of guns and crime. We were split between eight critics of the new law and two ardent supporters.
Here is what we heard from the law's supporters: It doesn't matter whether or not voter impersonation, which this law is designed to eliminate, is a common problem. The law is preventative. Yes, it could help Republicans in what is expected to be a close race in November, but that is because it will get rid of the cheating by Democrats that has been going on in Philadelphia for decades. President Obama and Mayor Nutter do not want integrity in elections — they want to win at all costs. Carrying ID at all times is a sign of personal responsibility. If you don't have one, "Put on your big boy, or big girl pants and get yourself an ID."
Here is what we heard from the law's critics: We have a bad history of all kinds of corruption here in Philadelphia, but voter impersonation has never been a problem. This law discriminates against people who already have the hardest time getting to the polls. Who can take a half-day off work to get a new ID from PennDOT? The 15th Amendment to the Constitution was passed in 1870. The Voting Rights Act was passed 95 years later because politicians were still finding ways to keep African-Americans from voting. This law continues a long and disgraceful history of voter suppression.
We all know we need to strike a balance between preventing voter fraud and allowing as many people as possible to vote. Perhaps voter ID is an appropriate step, but the opponents believe there is no way this requirement can be implemented fairly in the few months prior to an election. Take time to do it right, and take the necessary supplemental measures to support all those who would have a hard time getting an ID. Sadly, your People's Editorial Board was not able to reach consensus on this point.
Regardless, the priority now is to make sure democracy is accessible to everyone. Check out the bipartisan League of Women Voters and Committee of Seventy websites for more information on how to get appropriate IDs.