David Murphy: Surging Phillies still face long odds

Antonio Bastardo delivers a pitch during ninth inning of his save Monday night.
Antonio Bastardo delivers a pitch during ninth inning of his save Monday night. (STEVEN M. FALK/STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER)
Posted: September 12, 2012

JUDGING BY the large swaths of blue evident in many seating sections, Phillies fans are resistant to the strain of playoff fever that is supposedly wafting through the air at Citizens Bank Park. Multiple cases of disappointment can have that effect on a person. After 5 months of watching this team repeatedly go to great lengths to kill whatever momentum it possessed, folks are going to need to see more than a six-game wild-card deficit, the predicament entering Monday's games, before they are reinvigorated by a sense of purpose.

Sure, you can twist it so that it feels like the Phillies inhabit the realm of possibility, provided you are willing to deal in wishful thinking and logic that is not parallel (if you are a politician, in other words). You, for instance, can take solace in the fact that the deficit they face is smaller than the one the Cardinals overcame over the final 22 games of the 2011 season. But to do so, you must ignore the fact that the Cardinals were chasing one team, whereas the Phillies entered Monday chasing three teams and tied with a fourth. Even if they equaled St. Louis' 16-6 record down the stretch last September, they would need this year's version of the Cardinals to go no better than 10-12, and the Dodgers to go no better than 11-10 and the Pirates to go no better than 13-8, all just to force a four-way tie for the second-to-last wild-card spot.

Starting Sept. 18, the Cardinals play nine straight games against the Astros and the Cubs, the teams with the worst two records in the majors. The Dodgers have a tougher go of it, with a four-game series against the Cardinals and three-game series against NL East-leading Washington and NL Central-leading Cincinnati still on the schedule. Still, the Phillies have less than a 1 percent chance of qualifying for the postseason, at least according to the formula that ESPN uses to determine such things.

That we are even having the conversation is a victory of sorts for a team that was 14 games under .500 as recently as July 13. Since then, they are 33-20, a pace that over the course of a 162-game season would equate to 101 wins. All of it is enough to make you wonder where they would be had Chase Utley and Ryan Howard been healthy for an entire season, or if the bullpen had a couple of more weapons.

The real optimism isn't about this year's postseason, but about next year's regular season, because the Phillies' roster is at a point where it could use some pleasant surprises. Maybe Kyle Kendrick can fit into that category. In a 3-1 win over the Marlins on Monday night, he once again looked the part, carrying a no-hitter into the sixth inning and finishing with eight strikeouts in seven innings. A pitcher who entered the season with a career 4.41 ERA and 4.1 strikeouts-per-nine-innings average, now has a 3.83 ERA and a 6.6 K/9 average. If Kendrick really has discovered the key to consistent major league success - right now, it looks suspiciously like a changeup - it could more than offset the regression of Roy Halladay and the uncertainty surrounding Vance Worley.

Even more important than Kendrick are Domonic Brown and Antonio Bastardo, two players who factored heavily into Monday night's win. Brown, who entered the night hitting just .243 with a .320 on-base percentage and .339 slugging percentage in 128 plate appearances, crushed his second home run of the season, a two-run shot off lefty Wade LeBlanc in a three-run fifth inning. Bastardo pitched a scoreless ninth inning for the save. Both are the kind of player this club will need to regain its position atop the National League: they are cheap, and they play positions of need. Neither is close to earning the benefit of the doubt with regard to 2013, but nights like Monday show you a glimpse of the tools that keep earning them chances.

If those chances result in something to talk about for the final few weeks of the season, all the better. Monday night, Charlie Manuel estimated that the Phillies would need to win at least 14 or 15 of their remaining 21 games to have a shot at the second wild-card spot. To have a realistic chance, the number is probably more like 18 or 19. It isn't impossible, but it sure is unlikely. There are also far worse alternatives.


Contact Dave Murphy at dmurphy@phillynews.com. Follow him on Twitter @HighCheese. For Phillies coverage and opinion, read his blog at philly.com/HighCheese.

|
|
|
|
|