'The Oranges' tries and fails to make comedy of adultery

A liaison among family friends disrupts two households in "The Oranges."
A liaison among family friends disrupts two households in "The Oranges."
Posted: October 05, 2012

In the it-came-from-Sundance comedy "The Oranges," an affair tears apart two knit-together New Jersey families.

The affair is certainly scandalous. Some might also find it utterly preposterous. I sure did, and as a result, felt the movie labored under credibility problems beyond the reach of its top-notch cast.

Hugh Laurie and Catherine Keener are David and Paige Walling, long-marrieds in a powerful (though unexplained) lull - he's been spending a lot of nights on the couch lately.

Their BFFs across the street are the Ostroffs (Oliver Platt and Allison Janney) - the men jog together every morning, the women plot elaborate holidays together, and since one family is Christian and one Jewish, this collaboration occupies the entire calender year.

The movie opens at Thanksgiving, an occasion that Mrs. Ostroff wants to use to make the families closer still - with the grown children back home, she tries to fix up her visiting daughter (Leighton Meester) with the Wallings' highly eligible visiting son (Adam Brody).

There is an interfamily hookup, to be sure, though not the one mom has envisioned. This one is spontaneous, and unacceptable to almost everybody, though handled by director Julian Farino in a way that is meant to be amusing.

The movie strains to maintain its kooky-yet-melancholy tone and seems not to notice the implications of the liaison it sets forth.

Families like these, close families that car pool and babysit and co-manage the raising of children, don't go down this road.

Does it happen? Could it happen? Surely, as long as there is human weakness. But if and when it does, it ain't funny and would involve a pathology not in evidence in this movie.


Contact movie critic Gary Thompson at 215-854-5992 or thompsg@phillynews.com. Read his blog at philly.com/KeepItReel.

|
|
|
|
|