After provisional-ballot controversy, Butkovitz wants to audit election

Posted: November 21, 2012

BECAUSE MORE THAN 27,000 voters were required to cast provisional ballots on Election Day, City Controller Alan Butkovitz announced Tuesday that he wants to conduct an audit of this year's election process.

The number of voters who cast provisional ballots in this month's presidential election was more than double the amount in 2008, and Butkovitz said he wants to get to the bottom of it after election results are certified.

"It looks like there were an awful lot of complaints by people who said they've been in the poll books for years," Butkovitz said. "It's a matter that is driving a lot of public concern."

The city commissioners, who oversee elections, are reviewing the provisional ballots, a process that takes several weeks. Commissioner Al Schmidt - who, along with Commissioner Anthony Clark, dumped Commissioner Stephanie Singer as chairwoman after the election - said that he shares Butkovitz's "interest in the matter" and that a pre-audit meeting will take place next week.

Mayor Nutter will ask his staff to "make a thorough inquiry" into what happened on Election Day, mayoral spokesman Mark McDonald said.

Of the 10 largest U.S. cities, Philadelphia is the only one in which elected officials run elections, according to the government-watchdog group Committee of Seventy, which has called for eliminating the city commissioners as an elected office. That would require an amendment to the Home Rule Charter.

"In the past," McDonald said, "the mayor has mentioned the possibility of transforming some elected offices into administrative offices, but he's not addressing that issue at this point in time."

Butkovitz said his audit would address that issue as well.

Meanwhile, Singer on Monday sent out an email and posted a blog item about "infighting" among the city commissioners. She said that Schmidt and Clark, the new co-chairmen, showed little interest in an idea she had in September to use real-time tracking of provisional ballots on Election Day, which she said would have prevented many problems.

Singer also suggests in the blog post that the state Republican Party was behind the takeover of the city commissioners, and describes the alliance between Clark and Schmidt as "bad news for Democrats."

" @Jan_Ransom

Blog: PhillyClout.com

|
|
|
|
|