Inquirer Editorial: Armed officers not best answer to Sandy Hook

A sign welcomes Sandy Hook Elementary children to their new school.
A sign welcomes Sandy Hook Elementary children to their new school. (JESSICA HILL / Associated Press)
A sign welcomes Sandy Hook Elementary children to their new school.GALLERY: A sign welcomes Sandy Hook Elementary children to their… (JESSICA HILL…)
Posted: January 08, 2013

A New Jersey district's decision to put armed officers in every school doesn't mean that's the best way to promote safety.

The Marlboro school system took the extraordinary action last week after the holiday recess in response to the school rampage in Newtown, Conn., that left 20 first graders and six adults dead.

The Monmouth County district became the first in New Jersey to put an armed guard in every public school. Whether others follow suit seems doubtful. Gov. Christie opposes that approach, as does the New Jersey Education Association, the state's powerful teachers' union.

Some New Jersey schools, mostly high schools, do have armed officers. In Philadelphia, too, armed officers are assigned to some high schools. But, for the most part, they were placed in schools to reduce violence by students against their peers and teachers - not to deter random attacks by outsiders. Even so, armed guards can't guarantee safety, as seen in Philadelphia.

Marlboro School Superintendent David Abbott said the added police presence in his system would be temporary and was based on a request by township officials to "ratchet up" security in the 5,300-student district.

The district plans to spend $100,000 in overtime costs for uniformed, off-duty police officers to patrol its schools for the next three months.

Parents understandably are willing to take any action thought to protect their children, even if it means spending more to promote safety, and regardless of whether it will be effective.

Across the country, school districts, universities, and other institutions have grappled with finding better ways to keep students safe in the wake of the tragedy at Sandy Hook Elementary School.

The National Rifle Association has proposed putting an armed guard in every school in the nation. Hundreds of teachers in Utah accepted free firearms training. And U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer (D., Calif.) wants to use federal funds to deploy National Guard soldiers inside schools.

A more logical step to decrease the more common violence that occurs outside schools before and after classes is to increase the police presence along the routes that students travel.

Students must feel safe to concentrate on learning. But having armed police officers walk the hallways only makes them feel like they're in a prison. Many societal changes must be made to prevent another Sandy Hook, but more guns in the schools isn't one of them.

|
|
|
|
|