Nearly all the songs felt like through-composed ariosos, allowing Clearfield the elbow room to have texts spoken, whispered, and declaimed by mezzo-soprano Katherine Pracht and the wonderful baritone Randall Scarlata. But not until the last three songs did she truly bore deep into the meaning of the text with full-fisted piano writing (well-handled by Laura Ward) and vocal lines of considerable literary sensitivity. Schubert was echoed in the quirky, repeating melodies heard in her setting of the Friedrich Hölderlin poem "Half of Life."
While Clearfield's piece was the more outwardly impressive, Hagen's After Words for soprano and tenor was more deeply insinuating, more Italianate in its vocal lines, and with a launch point that hooked you before the piece began: The six songs were dialogues between two angels, happily recalling Hindemith's cycle Das Marienleben for its poetic, personal, anti-iconographic contemplation of the sacred.
With their bird's-eye perspectives, the angels observed life and death (such as the hurdy-gurdy man described in Winterreise), asking existential questions that humans do when not too busy running around living. Playful at times, each song had inner emotional intensity, creating a world you didn't want to leave.
The laudably text-attentive soprano Justine Aronson had a bright voice that turned a bit brittle when pushed. Joseph Gaines, brought in on short notice when the original singer canceled, completely embodied the music with his light tenor, committing body and soul to the music in ways one rarely sees.
Contact David Patrick Stearns at email@example.com.