But it always will be a three-pointer from way beyond the arc that tied the score at 48 with 37 seconds remaining in the Group 4 state final in the Rutgers Athletic Center.
"It was one of those moments," Reynolds said after Atlantic City, fueled by his remarkable shot and a pair of three-pointers in overtime by junior guard Isiah Graves, rallied for a 60-54 victory over Linden. "[My teammates] count on me. I'd rather it all fall on me than anyone else."
That's true leadership, that willingness to bear the brunt of the burden for the team.
See, it's easy to rave about Reynolds since the shot hit nothing but net and the Vikings used the momentum of that moment to capture their second consecutive state title and third in the last nine seasons under coach Gene Allen.
But what might be more telling than the success of the shot was the willingness to take it.
Allen said the Vikings had called a play during a timeout after Linden took a 48-45 lead on a three-point play by Josh Carter with 47 seconds left.
Just 10 seconds into the ensuing possession, Reynolds saw an opening and let fly with the single biggest shot of the South Jersey basketball season.
"Thank God," Allen said of his reaction when Reynolds rose up for the shot.
Here's what the coach meant: He was happy that his team wasn't going to waste critical moments looking for the perfect shot, only to rush to come up with an alternative as the clock ran down.
He also was happy that Reynolds was the player who seized the initiative.
But he wasn't surprised.
"That's senior leadership," Allen said of Reynolds, a 6-foot-1 lefthander who averages 10.2 points. "That type of player is rare to find. I may never get a kid like that again. He's special. He takes responsibility."
Reynolds' basketball heroics are somewhat surprising since football is his main sport. He has committed to Temple on a football scholarship, although he might attend prep school and join the Owls program in January.
Reynolds' uncle, the late Jamar Reynolds, was a star running back on the only Atlantic City team to win a South Jersey title in football, beating the Adam Taliaferro-led Eastern team by 31-29 in the Group 4 championship game in 1999.
Dayshawn Reynolds was a first-team all-South Jersey wide receiver during the fall. He made 50 catches for 910 yards and 10 touchdowns.
"I'm committed to football," Reynolds said. "But I'm with this basketball team from top to bottom. I'd do anything for this basketball team."
Reynolds did something special on Sunday, making one of the biggest shots in the history of the proud program.
But to make it, he had to be willing to take it - and that said as much about his leadership and competitive heart as the sight of that basketball splashing through the rim.
Phil Anastasia: Tournament of Champions
No. 3 seed Atlantic City (29-1)
vs. No. 6 Point Pleasant Beach (27-3)
When: 8 p.m. Wednesday.
Where: Pine Belt Arena at Toms River North High School.
Atlantic City's road to T of C: Beat Toms River South, 67-43; Southern, 61-56; Toms River North, 56-36; Lenape, 51-40 (South Jersey Group 4 final); East Brunswick, 51-49; Linden, 60-54 OT (Group 4 state final).
Point Pleasant Beach's road to T of C: Beat Metuchen, 70-34; Keansburg, 69-45; Shore, 60-47; Bound Brook, 69-40 (Central Jersey Group 1 final); Paulsboro, 67-48; Dayton, 43-39 (Group 1 state final).
What's next: The winner will play No. 2 seed St. Joseph of Metuchen (27-4), the Non-Public A champion, in the T of C semifinals at 6 p.m. Friday at Monmouth University.
Fast fact: In two previous appearances in the T of C, Atlantic City won first-round games in 2005 and 2012.
Did you know?: Point Pleasant Beach senior forward Riley Calzonetti, who scored 18 points in the state final, is the son of former Paul VI star Mark Calzonetti, now an assistant coach at Long Island University in Brooklyn.
- Phil Anastasia
Contact Phil Anastasia at firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow on Twitter @PhilAnastasia. Read his blog, "Jersey Side Sports," at www.philly.com/