Camden outscored St. Anthony by 22-12 in the fourth quarter, and it was no fluke - the Friars' regulars were in the game and playing as hard as they did in the first 24 minutes.
"That was their pride," legendary St. Anthony coach Bob Hurley said after the game on the court that bears his name. "They're such tough kids. They played with the intensity that Camden is known for."
Holloway and fellow sophomore Brad Hawkins led the way for Camden (6-2), the No. 10 team in The Inquirer Top 10.
Holloway collected 10 rebounds with eight points, while Hawkins led all scorers with 14 and also generated four rebounds, three assists and two steals.
"This was a good experience," Hawkins said. "This game will help us for the rest of the season. We know we can play with teams like this."
Junior forward Markis McDuffie scored 13 points and senior guard Tarin Smith added 11 for St. Anthony (8-1).
Hurley is the country's active leader in coaching victories. Tuesday night's win was the 1,085th of his career.
The game in the little gymnasium at the Community Education and Recreation Center off Ninth Street in the heart of Jersey City matched two of the most fabled boys' basketball programs in New Jersey history.
The game started about a half-hour late because Camden was caught in "brutal traffic" on a rainy afternoon, according to assistant coach Vic Carstarphen.
The Panthers still seemed stuck in slow motion through the first three quarters, although St. Anthony's size, depth and defensive diligence were major road blocks for the visitors.
"We can talk about what it's going to be like but they just don't understand what the pressure is going to be like when you face a defense like that," Camden coach John Valore said. "They're kids. They were anxious. They wanted to play well and they rushed a lot of things."
Camden roared back in the final eight minutes as junior Will McCants scored all eight of his points and junior Rasool Hinson scored five of his seven.
Camden 2 9 8 22 - 41
St. Anthony 10 15 19 12 - 56
C: Brad Hawkins 14, Jamal Holloway 8, Rasool Hinson 7, Will McCants 8, Jamil Maddred 4.
SA: Tarin Smith 11, Markis McDuffie 13, Ed Dominguez 6, Idris Joyner 5, Cheddi Mosley 6, Shaquille McFarlan 9, Mohamed Bendary 2, Jaquan Mosley 4.