"As a community standing in solidarity with nonviolent protesters across the country, we are extremely uncomfortable honoring you," a group of 50 Haverford students and professors wrote to Birgeneau. "To do so would be a disservice to those nonviolent protesters who were beaten and whose actions you dismissed as 'unfortunate,' as if they brought the abuse upon themselves."
But, the group said, they would support his appearance if he met nine conditions - including publicly apologizing, supporting reparations for the victims, and writing a letter to Haverford students explaining his position on the events and "what you learned from them."
Birgeneau's response? No way.
"First, I have never and will never respond to lists of demands. Second, as a longtime civil rights activist and firm supporter of nonviolence, I do not respond to untruthful, violent verbal attacks," his letter read in its entirety.
Picking commencement speakers has become increasingly divisive. Former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice on Saturday pulled out of Rutgers University' commencement speech after faculty and student protests. Last year, there was a problem at Swarthmore College.
Haverford president Daniel H. Weiss, who has called a meeting of the Haverford community for 5 p.m. Thursday, said he was concerned over the students' issuing of demands to a speaker who was appropriately selected.
"The letter," Weiss wrote to the students, "read more like a jury issuing a verdict than as an invitation to discussion or a request for shared learning."
He called Birgeneau "one of the most influential and important higher education leaders in our generation."
"It's in that context that we want to honor him," Weiss said.
Of the 2011 incident, Weiss said: "He accepted responsibility and he apologized."
Michael Rushmore, a senior, said he was shocked at Birgeneau's response.
"He basically said, 'Screw you,' " said Rushmore, 23, a political science major from London.
Students, he said, haven't decided what they will do next. They don't want to be disruptive at commencement, he said, but remain concerned that Birgeneau will be associated with it.
"The only way," he said, "I want to be associated with Robert Birgeneau is in opposition to him."