With Friday's results, all nine of the alumni trustees who served on the 32-member board when former assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky was indicted in November 2011 have been replaced.
"The alumni want change," said Alice W. Pope, an associate professor of psychology at St. John's University in Queens, N.Y., who came in first with more than 10,000 votes. "I'm going to work as hard as I can to bridge the divide between the old and the new trustees so we can work together to fix the mistakes of the past and move Penn State into a glorious future."
Pope was hugged and high-fived as she stood in the audience at the board of trustees meeting Friday where the results were announced. More than 29,000 alumni voted over the last couple of months.
Al Lord, former chairman and CEO of student lender Sallie Mae, finished second with more than 9,500 votes. Former State Sen. Robert Jubelirer, who also attended the meeting, won the third seat with more than 8,000 votes.
"We have a very divided Penn State community that needs a lot of healing," said Jubelirer, a Republican.
Jubelirer said he has been in a dozen elections during his life, but never experienced one as "nasty" as this one.
"My whole personal life was laid out on Facebook," he said.
All three were endorsed by Penn Staters for Responsible Stewardship, a group that formed after the scandal broke. The same group got three trustees elected last year and two in 2012.
The announcement of new trustees came at the same meeting where the board said farewell to president Rodney Erickson.
The board voted unanimously to up Erickson's bonus by $50,000 to $150,000, created a discovery grant program in his name to assist students with research, and named the food sciences building, home to the famous Berkey Creamery, after him. The board also awarded him the coveted Penn State medal, which only two other former presidents, Bryce Jordan and Joab Thomas, have received.
"He's a saint," board chair Keith Masser said. "We asked him to take over this job at the most challenging time, and he stepped into the fray. This university owes him a debt of gratitude."
Erickson became president in November 2011 when former president Graham B. Spanier was forced out in the wake of revelations that Sandusky sexually abused boys on and off campus. He led the university through its recovery and signed off on sanctions handed down by the NCAA - one of his most controversial acts.
"Thank you again for the privilege of serving the university for 37 years," Erickson said.
Board member Anthony P. Lubrano, who has opposed the decision to succumb to the sanctions and other decisions Erickson made, voted yes on every measure to honor him.
"You can't make any of this personal," Lubrano said. "In the scheme of all of this, when we consider contributions that people have made to this institution, we have to look at the entire picture."
The board also welcomed four other new members: Cliff Benson, chief development officer of the Buffalo Sabres and a PSU grad, and Todd Rucci, governmental and community relations officer with PAP Technologies, both gubernatorial appointments; and Daniel S. Mead, president and CEO of Verizon Wireless, and Walter C. Rakowich, retired CEO of Prologis, both business and industry appointees.